Columbus Crew 
| 2009-03-21 | MLS | Houston Dynamo | (A) | 1 | - 1 | D | |
| 2009-03-28 | MLS | Toronto FC | (H) | 1 | - 1 | D | |
| 2009-04-02 | MLS | Real Salt Lake | (A) | 1 | - 4 | L | |
| 2009-04-05 | MLS | CD Chivas USA | (A) | 1 | - 2 | L | |
| 2009-04-11 | MLS | Colorado Rapids | (H) | 1 | - 1 | D | |
| 2009-04-25 | MLS | Chicago Fire SC | (H) | 2 | - 2 | D | |
| 2009-05-02 | MLS | Toronto FC | (A) | 1 | - 1 | D | |
| 2009-05-09 | MLS | Sporting Kansas City | (H) | 3 | - 2 | W | |
| 2009-05-17 | MLS | Los Angeles Galaxy | (A) | 1 | - 1 | D | |
| 2009-05-27 | MLS | San Jose Earthquakes | (H) | 2 | - 1 | W | |
| 2009-05-30 | MLS | Seattle Sounders FC | (A) | 1 | - 1 | D | |
| 2009-06-06 | MLS | Sporting Kansas City | (A) | 2 | - 0 | W | |
| 2009-06-14 | MLS | CD Chivas USA | (H) | 2 | - 1 | W | |
| 2009-06-20 | MLS | FC Dallas | (A) | 1 | - 2 | L | |
| 2009-06-27 | MLS | New York Red Bulls | (H) | 1 | - 0 | W | |
| 2009-07-04 | MLS | D.C. United | (H) | 1 | - 1 | D | |
| 2009-07-11 | MLS | Chicago Fire SC | (A) | 0 | - 0 | D | |
| 2009-07-18 | MLS | Real Salt Lake | (H) | 3 | - 1 | W | |
| 2009-07-25 | MLS | Toronto FC | (H) | 3 | - 2 | W | |
| 2009-08-01 | MLS | Colorado Rapids | (A) | 1 | - 0 | W | |
| 2009-08-08 | MLS | San Jose Earthquakes | (A) | 3 | - 0 | W | |
| 2009-08-15 | MLS | FC Dallas | (H) | 2 | - 0 | W | |
| 2009-08-30 | MLS | New York Red Bulls | (A) | 0 | - 1 | L | |
| 2009-09-13 | MLS | Houston Dynamo | (H) | 2 | - 1 | W | |
| 2009-09-20 | MLS | Chicago Fire SC | (A) | 2 | - 2 | D | |
| 2009-09-26 | MLS | Los Angeles Galaxy | (H) | 2 | - 0 | W | |
| 2009-10-03 | MLS | Seattle Sounders FC | (H) | 0 | - 1 | L | |
| 2009-10-10 | MLS | New England Revolution | (A) | 1 | - 0 | W | |
| 2009-10-18 | MLS | D.C. United | (A) | 0 | - 1 | L | |
| 2009-10-25 | MLS | New England Revolution | (H) | 0 | - 1 | L |